Games like Army of Tentacles: Not A Cthulhu Dating Sim - Black Goat of the Woods Edition

If you finished Army of Tentacles: Not A Cthulhu Dating Sim - Black Goat of the Woods Edition, the closest matches are Omensight, Torchlight III, Star Control: Origins, Tanzia and Survivalist. All 6 share its adventure genre and are ranked by how closely their themes and modes overlap.