If you liked this
Games like Cats & Carnations
If you finished Cats & Carnations, the closest matches are A Date with Death, Ballads at Midnight, Seers Isle, Arcana Twilight and When the Night Comes. All 12 share its indie genre and are ranked by how closely their themes and modes overlap.
A Date with Death
Ballads at Midnight
Seers Isle
Arcana Twilight
When the Night Comes
Peachleaf Valley: Seeds of Love
Diabolik Lovers: Haunted Dark Bridal
Diabolik Lovers: Lost Eden
Celestia
Kami-sama Hajimemashita: Doki-doki Ayakashi Love
Ikemen Vampire: Temptation in the Dark
