Games like Don't Stare

If you finished Don't Stare, the closest matches are The Warfstache Clicker, Pranksterz: From Russia With Love, Another FNaF Fangame: Open Source, Nasty Neighbors: No Picnic for Celebrity and Pranksterz: No Rest for the Wicked. All 10 share its arcade genre and are ranked by how closely their themes and modes overlap.