Games like Kimi ni Todoke: Tsutaeru Kimochi

If you finished Kimi ni Todoke: Tsutaeru Kimochi, the closest matches are 12-Sai: Honto no Kimochi, Kimi ni Todoke: Sodateru Omoi, Ouran High School Host Club, Number Days Sim Date and Kami-sama Hajimemashita: Doki-doki Ayakashi Love. All 6 share its visual novel genre and are ranked by how closely their themes and modes overlap.