If you liked this
Games like MakeShift Mayhem
If you finished MakeShift Mayhem, the closest matches are Star Citizen, Hytale, Cairn, No Man's Sky and Mewgenics. All 36 share its adventure genre and are ranked by how closely their themes and modes overlap.
Star Citizen
80
Hytale
87
Cairn
74
No Man's Sky
91
Mewgenics
92
Abiotic Factor
90
Welcome to Elderfield
80
Pathologic 3
80
Escape the Backrooms
86
Wanderstop
82
Skate Story
89
Nighthawks
94
Caves of Qud
93
Cult of the Lamb: Woolhaven
70
Will: Follow the Light
85
Starsand Island
95
Slay the Princess: The Pristine Cut
72
Outbound
87
Promise Mascot Agency
80
Strange Antiquities
90
Keep Driving
80
Retrospace
76
Solarpunk
84
Pacific Drive
86
Dredge
86
Core Keeper
87
The Jackbox Party Pack 11
80
The Coin Game
93
The Exit 8
70
Winter Burrow
79
Collector's Cove
90
Pacific Drive: Whispers in the Woods
92
Copycat
85
Back to the Dawn
85
Dead In Antares
89